Health Policy And Planning[JOURNAL]
Sun
200 papers
Correction to: Indonesian medical interns' intention to practice in rural areas.
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Apr · PMID 39937614 · Full text
Abstract loading — click title to view on PubMed.
Institutionalizing linkages between informal healthcare providers and the formal health system in Nigeria: what are the facilitating and constraining contextual influences?
Onwujekwe O, Mbachu CO, Agyepong I … +1 more , Elsey H
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Apr · PMID 39913199 · Full text
With most households in rapidly urbanizing cities in low- and medium-income countries using private and informal providers for basic healthcare, the need to establish linkages with the formal sector is paramount in the d...
With most households in rapidly urbanizing cities in low- and medium-income countries using private and informal providers for basic healthcare, the need to establish linkages with the formal sector is paramount in the drive for universal health coverage. Successful and effective linkage of informal healthcare providers to the formal health system requires an understanding of prevailing contextual factors and how they can be modulated to support the linkages. Context plays a pivotal role in shaping the nature and success of any integration efforts. This paper, based on a qualitative study, explored the facilitating and constraining contextual influences shaping the linkage of informal healthcare providers into the formal health system in governance, service delivery, and data reporting. The research was conducted in Enugu and Anambra states in southeastern Nigeria. In-depth interviews were held with 12 senior healthcare managers, 16 primary healthcare facility managers, 32 informal providers, and 16 community leaders. Eight sex-disaggregated focus group discussions were held with health service users. Transcripts were coded in NVivo using a pre-defined coding framework comprising facilitators and constraints at the individual, organisational, and environmental levels. Individual factors that influence linkage of informal providers into the formal health system include personal attitudes towards linkage, capacity of informal providers to deliver quality services, nature of existing relationships between formal and informal providers, and trust in the formal health system. Organizational factors include leadership structure, coordination and accountability mechanisms, functional management capacity of the formal health system, and multiple regulatory frameworks. External factors include supportive health policies on integration, sustainable funding for continuous training and supportive supervision, and global agenda/support for integration. This study has provided valuable insights for decision makers and practitioners for harnessing the contextual factors to link informal healthcare providers successfully and effectively to the formal health system in order to improve access to quality health services in urban slums.
A political economy analysis of health policymaking in Nigeria: the genesis of the 2014 National Health Act.
Chukwuma JN, Obi FA
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Apr · PMID 39882935 · Full text
This article explores the ideologies, interests, and institutions affecting health policymaking in Nigeria, and the role of the private sector therein. It covers the period from the late-1950s, the years leading up to in...
This article explores the ideologies, interests, and institutions affecting health policymaking in Nigeria, and the role of the private sector therein. It covers the period from the late-1950s, the years leading up to independence, to 2014, when the country enacted its first-ever law to govern its healthcare system. The National Health Act (NHAct) was adopted after a decade of preparation and civil society-driven advocacy, making the objective of universal health coverage (UHC) explicit. However, in its final version, the NHAct earmarked only a small share of public funds for UHC, solidifying the country's reliance on private healthcare and out-of-pocket payments. To examine the specific set of ideologies, interests, and institutions defining Nigeria's pathway toward UHC and the contribution of the private sector, we adopted the political economy framework, situating the genesis of the 2014 NHAct within the broader political and economic context of Nigeria's health system reform process since the 1950s. Drawing on qualitative data collected during interviews and focus groups, we found that the deep entrenchment of private-sector healthcare in Nigeria is the result of a path-dependent process. This implies that Nigeria's current reliance on the private sector is influenced by historical patterns, competing interests, and institutional practices that have reinforced the role of private actors over time. We identified three major explanatory factors that have shaped health policymaking in Nigeria. First, since the 1980s, the ideology that private healthcare is the solution to an underfunded and underperforming public healthcare system has been reinforced by leading international organizations. Second, private actors in Nigeria have been in a strong position to influence health policymaking since independence. Third, Nigeria's challenging socio-economic context and the limitations of its federal governance structure have fostered a general level of public distrust in the capacity of the public sector to provide quality healthcare.
Correction to: Capacity and crisis: examining the state-level policy response to COVID-19 in Tamil Nadu, India.
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39854176 · Full text
Abstract loading — click title to view on PubMed.
Can public education campaigns equitably counter the use of substandard and falsified medical products in African countries?
Wagnild JM, Owusu SA, Mariwah S … +10 more , Kolo VI, Vandi A, Namanya DB, Kuwana R, Jayeola B, Prah-Ashun V, Adeyeye MC, Komeh J, Nahamya D, Hampshire K
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Apr · PMID 39825861 · Full text
Substandard and falsified (SF) medical products are a serious health and economic concern that disproportionately impact low- and middle-income countries and marginalized groups. Public education campaigns are demand-sid...
Substandard and falsified (SF) medical products are a serious health and economic concern that disproportionately impact low- and middle-income countries and marginalized groups. Public education campaigns are demand-side interventions that may reduce the risk of SF exposure, but the effectiveness of such campaigns, and their likelihood of benefitting everybody, is unclear. Nationwide pilot risk communication campaigns, involving multiple media, were deployed in Ghana, Nigeria, Sierra Leone, and Uganda in 2020-21. Focus group discussions (n = 73 with n = 611 total participants) and key informant interviews (n = 80 individual interviews and n = 4 group interviews with n = 111 total informants) were conducted within each of the four countries to ascertain the reach and effectiveness of the campaign. Small proportions of focus group discussants (8.0-13.9%) and key informants (12.5-31.4%) had previously encountered the campaign materials. Understandability varied: the use of English and select local languages, combined with high rates of illiteracy, meant that some were not able to understand the campaign. The capacity for people to act on the messages was extremely limited: inaccessibility, unavailability, and unaffordability of quality-assured medicines from official sources, as well as illiteracy, constrained what people could realistically do in response to the campaign. Importantly, reach, understandability, and capacity to respond were especially limited among marginalized groups, who are already at the greatest risk of exposure to SF products. These findings suggest that there may be potential for public education campaigns to help combat the issue of SF medicines through prevention, but that the impact of public education is likely to be limited and may even inadvertently widen health inequities. This indicates that public education campaigns are not a single solution; they can only be properly effective if accompanied by health system strengthening and supply-side interventions that aim to increase the effectiveness of regulation.
How has the concept of health system software been used in health policy and systems research? A scoping review.
Burger N, Gilson L
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39821049 · Full text
Understanding health systems as comprising interacting elements of hardware and software acknowledges health systems as complex adaptive systems (CASs). Hardware represents the concrete components of systems, whereas sof...
Understanding health systems as comprising interacting elements of hardware and software acknowledges health systems as complex adaptive systems (CASs). Hardware represents the concrete components of systems, whereas software represents the elements that influence actions and underpin relationships, such as processes, values, and norms. As a specific call for research on health system software was made in 2011, we conducted a qualitative scoping review considering how and for what purpose the concept has been used since then. Our overall purpose was to synthesize current knowledge and generate lessons about how to deepen research on, and understanding of, health system software. The review consisted of two phases: first, for the period 2011-23, all papers that explicitly used the concept of health system software were identified and mapped; second, drawing on a subset of papers from Phase 1, we explored how the concept was purposively used within research. The databases PubMed, Scopus, EBSCOhost, Web of Science, and Google Scholar were systematically searched using a strategy developed by a skilled librarian. In Phase 1, data were extracted from 98 papers. Our analysis revealed that a third of the papers used the software concept rather superficially; a third used it to conceptualize the importance of selected software elements; and a third used it in examining a specific health system experience, such as preparedness or resilience. In Phase 2, our analysis confirmed that researchers have found value in proactively using the software concept within studies, demonstrating two patterns of use. However, a limited understanding of how to investigate interactions among hardware and software elements was also revealed. Future health policy and systems research should purposively investigate hardware-software interactions in order to gain a greater understanding of the complex, adaptive nature of health systems, understand their operations, and institutionalize thinking that considers health systems as CASs.
Strengthening local health systems and governance for Universal Health Coverage: experiences and lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic response in Quezon City, Philippines.
Escano-Arias EA, Abarquez RADG, Cruz RV … +6 more , Espeleta R, Ong MM, Loreche AM, Pepito VCF, Gomez V, Dayrit MM
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39801295 · Full text
The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted the Philippines's transition toward universal health coverage. However, some local government units in the country made use of the pandemic as a catalyst to strengthen their local heal...
The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted the Philippines's transition toward universal health coverage. However, some local government units in the country made use of the pandemic as a catalyst to strengthen their local health system, scale-up the provision of preventive and primary care services, and improve health governance to make it more prepared to face future pandemics and realize the aims of the country's new Universal Healthcare Act. This paper describes the response of the local government of Quezon City, Philippines, to COVID-19 and how it strengthened local health systems. We also discuss enablers such as partnerships, collaborations, and foresight to ensure that investments during the pandemic will continue to be of use. We also identify some constraints and propose recommendations to consolidate local health system gains during the COVID-19 pandemic response in the transition toward universal health coverage.
Correction to: Hospital response to a new case-based payment system in China: the patient selection effect.
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39731405 · Full text
Abstract loading — click title to view on PubMed.
The availability of essential medicines in public healthcare facilities in Afghanistan: navigating sociopolitical and geographical challenges.
van Gurp M, Alba S, Ammiwala M … +7 more , Arab SR, Sadaat SM, Hanifi F, Safi S, Ansari N, Campos-Ponce M, Kok MO
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39697139 · Full text
During the past two decades, the Afghan government, along with the international community, has developed a system aimed at improving access to essential healthcare services under Afghanistan's challenging sociopolitical...
During the past two decades, the Afghan government, along with the international community, has developed a system aimed at improving access to essential healthcare services under Afghanistan's challenging sociopolitical and geographical circumstances. In 31 provinces, nonstate actors competed for fixed-term contracts to implement a predefined package of healthcare services. In three provinces, the government organized the provision of healthcare services. An independent third party monitored service provision, including access to medicines. This study examines the availability of essential medicines in Afghanistan's public healthcare facilities and how this is shaped by sociopolitical challenges, geographical barriers, and the organization of the healthcare system. Between March and July 2021, enumerators collected data at 885 healthcare facilities across Afghanistan. For our analysis, we combined data on medicine availability and the functioning of the health system with publicly available information about geographical and sociopolitical factors, including security incidents. Using regression analysis, we identified facility-, district-, and provincial-level factors related to medicine availability in public healthcare facilities. On average, 70% of 31 selected essential medicines were available in 2021. The availability of medicines varied significantly between provinces and was considerably higher in those where services were contracted out to nonstate actors (n = 31; 91%) compared to provinces where service provision was organized by the government (n = 3; 9%). The most important drivers of variation in medicine availability included geographical barriers, securing and allocating funds at the provincial level, and organizing and sustaining physical capacity at the facility level. Insecurity was not a key factor driving variation in medicine availability. Despite the sociopolitical challenges in 2021, the availability of essential medicines in public healthcare facilities was relatively high. The results suggest that decentralized procurement of medicines by nonstate actors and timely payment of funds contribute to medicine availability. Strategies to improve medicine availability should target hard-to-reach areas and lower-level facilities.
Maternal and perinatal mortality: geospatial analysis of inequality in pregnancy related and perinatal mortality in Ethiopia.
Alemu SM, Weitkamp G, Tura AK … +3 more , Wong KL, Stekelenburg J, Biesma R
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39686853 · Full text
While there is ample evidence of the overall reduction in perinatal and pregnancy-related mortality in Ethiopia, it remains uncertain if geographic disparities have diminished. This study aimed to investigate perinatal a...
While there is ample evidence of the overall reduction in perinatal and pregnancy-related mortality in Ethiopia, it remains uncertain if geographic disparities have diminished. This study aimed to investigate perinatal and pregnancy-related mortality spatial distributions, trends over time, and factors associated with the distribution in Ethiopia. We used data from Ethiopian Demographic and Health Surveys conducted in 2000, 2005, 2011, and 2016. In each survey, around 15 500 women aged 15-49 years were interviewed from about 550 neighborhoods randomly sampled from across the country. Perinatal and pregnancy-related mortality were used as outcome variables. We carried out an optimized hotspot analysis using the Getis-Ord Gi* statistic in ArcGIS Pro to identify the time trend of geographical clusters with high (hot spot) and low (cold spot) perinatal and pregnancy-related mortality. In addition, we conducted a geographically weighted Poisson regression in R to examine the factors associated with the spatial distribution of perinatal and pregnancy-related mortality. Perinatal and pregnancy-related mortality exhibited a clustering pattern, indicating the presence of geographic inequality, with a decreasing pattern from 2000 to 2016. We detected hotspot areas in developed administrative regions of Amhara, Oromia, and Southern Nations, indicating inequality within large regions. Inequality in perinatal mortality was associated with rural residence, younger age of women, and high birth rate, whereas pregnancy-related mortality was associated with low autonomy, younger age, and anemia. We found that anemia (P-value = .01) has a geographically varying relationship with perinatal mortality, while education (P-value = .03) and wealth (P-value = 0.01) are associated with pregnancy-related mortality. While there has been a reduction during the study period, geographical disparities in perinatal and pregnancy-related mortality still persist. Therefore, targeting intervention programs in areas where spatial inequalities still persist is essential for effectively utilizing scarce resources.
Maternal health planning and prioritization in Chad: developing a supportive tool.
Krause A, Quach A, Betinbaye Y … +3 more , Rolande M, Mgawadere F, Ameh CA
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39673767 · Full text
The Republic of Chad has one of the highest rates of maternal mortality in the world. With scarce resources to respond to competing demands, pragmatic evidence-based planning tools are needed to aid planning and support...
The Republic of Chad has one of the highest rates of maternal mortality in the world. With scarce resources to respond to competing demands, pragmatic evidence-based planning tools are needed to aid planning and support priority setting. This action research aimed to develop a tool to support maternal health (MH) planning and prioritization decisions and identify priority regions/provinces for intervention in Chad based on aggregate MH coverage gap scores (Target-Coverage = Coverage Gap). A rapid review was conducted to identify key indicators and relevant national targets. The 2019 Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey and other national surveys were the data sources for selected indicators at the provincial level. Aggregate MH coverage gaps were calculated and displayed using geographic information system software to visualize variations by province. Eleven key informant interviews (KIIs) and six focus group discussions (FGDs) were conducted with clinicians and administrators to understand existing MH planning, prioritization, and maternal mortality risks in Chad. Wide provincial variation in aggregate MH coverage gaps was identified (mean score 374.3, SD: 77.4). Indicators contributing the most to coverage gaps include emergency obstetric care, adolescent births, tetanus vaccination, and delivery by skilled health personnel. Two weighting scenarios for the coverage gap scores are also considered. KIIs and FGDs revealed that existing MH planning in Chad differs provincially and by health system level, with no clear prioritization processes identified. Main themes regarding MH risks reported by stakeholders included challenges relating to the health system, policy landscape, country and population-specific factors, along with specific MH threats. Current centralized planning approaches may benefit from greater consideration of provincial differences to support more efficient and equitable resource distribution. This multi-indicator assessment offers an adaptable approach for evidence-based MH resource allocation to prioritize subnational areas with worst health indicators in resource-limited settings, although further research is needed to test its impact.
The discrepancy between objective and subjective assessments of catastrophic health expenditure: evidence from China.
Guo B, Liu C, Yao Q
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39673411 · Full text
The pro-rich nature of catastrophic health expenditure (CHE) indicators has garnered criticism, inspiring the exploration of the subjective approach as a complementary method. However, no studies have examined the discre...
The pro-rich nature of catastrophic health expenditure (CHE) indicators has garnered criticism, inspiring the exploration of the subjective approach as a complementary method. However, no studies have examined the discrepancy between subjective and objective approaches. Employing data from the Chinese Social Survey (CSS) 2013-2021 waves, we analysed the discrepancy between objective and subjective CHE and its associated socioeconomic factors using logit regression modelling. Overall, self-rating generated higher CHE incidence (28.35% to 33.72%) compared to objective indicators (9.92% to 21.97%). Objective indicators did not support 17.57% to 23.90% of self-rated cases of household CHE, while 2.73% to 8.42% of households classified with CHE by objective indicators did not self-rate with CHE. The normative subsistence spending indicator showed the least consistency with self-rating (70.66% to 74.28%), while the budget share method produced the most consistent estimation (72.73% to 76.10%). Living with elderly and young children [adjusted odds ratios (AOR): 1.069 to 1.169, P < 0.1], lower educational attainment (AOR: 1.106 to 1.225, P < 0.1), lower income (AOR: 1.394 to 2.062, P < 0.01), and lower perceived social class (AOR: 1.537 to 2.801, P < 0.05) were associated with higher odds of self-rated CHE without support from objective indicators. Conversely, low socioeconomic status (AOR: 0.324 to 0.819, P < 0.1) was associated with lower odds of missing CHE cases classified by objective indicators in self-rating. The commonly used objective indicators for assessing CHE may attract doubts about their fairness from socioeconomically disadvantaged people. The CHE subjective approach can be adopted as a complementary measure to monitor financial risk protection.
Beyond access to sanitary pads: a comprehensive analysis of menstrual health scheme impact among rural girls in Northeast India.
Achuthan K, Khobragade S, Kolil VK
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Feb · PMID 39663667 · Full text
Menstrual hygiene management (MHM) among girls in rural India poses a substantial challenge for public health, education, and quality of life, exacerbated by limited access to and affordability of menstrual products. In...
Menstrual hygiene management (MHM) among girls in rural India poses a substantial challenge for public health, education, and quality of life, exacerbated by limited access to and affordability of menstrual products. In response to these issues, the Government of India initiated the Menstrual Hygiene Scheme (MHS) to enhance access and awareness. This study evaluates the impact of the MHS in Assam and Tripura, designated as "treatment states" with consistent pad supply from 2017 to 2021 compared to neighboring "control states" with negligible pad distribution. Utilizing data from two National Family Health Surveys, NFHS-4 and NFHS-5, and employing the propensity score matching difference-in-differences approach, we isolated the causal effect of the MHS distribution program. The key findings reveal a significant rise in sanitary pad and hygienic method usage in the treatment states, particularly among girls aged 15-19 years who received pads during the survey period. Their sanitary pad usage increased by 10.6 percentage points [95% confidence interval (CI) (0.046, 0.167)], and adoption of hygienic methods overall saw a 13.8 percentage point [95% CI (0.087, 0.188)] jump. Notably, younger girls aged 15-19 years also experienced a 6.1-percentage point [95% CI (0.004, 0.118)] increase in their understanding of ovulation, showcasing the MHS's potential to go beyond providing products and promoting menstrual health awareness. A rise in reported sexually transmitted infections in both age groups, with a statistically significant 1.8-percentage point [95% CI (0.004, 0.032)] increase for younger girls, warrants further exploration. Disparities in impact were observed, with girls with high media exposure and greater autonomy demonstrating greater improvements in hygienic practices, highlighting the importance of information dissemination and empowering girls. Most socioeconomic groups, except the highest wealth and education levels, witnessed rises in hygienic method usage, indicating the scheme's potential to reduce inequalities while hinting at the need for tailored interventions for marginalized communities.
Implementation science research priorities for Universal Health Coverage: methodological lessons from the design and implementation of a multicountry modified Delphi study.
Wodnik BK, Namyalo PK, Michaelides O … +3 more , Essue BM, Kane S, Di Ruggiero E
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39658269 · Full text
Delphi studies are rapidly gaining prominence in global health research. However, researchers' modifications to the Delphi method are often not well-described or justified, limiting opportunities to systematically learn...
Delphi studies are rapidly gaining prominence in global health research. However, researchers' modifications to the Delphi method are often not well-described or justified, limiting opportunities to systematically learn from these studies when the methods are applied to other topics and settings. This paper aims to describe an approach to implementing a modified Delphi study and reflect on the research process in the context of a multicountry study of implementation science research priorities to advance Universal Health Coverage (UHC). We review trends in the use of the modified Delphi method in global health research, outline our three-phased modified Delphi approach, and share reflections on five decision points for implementing the study: (I) identifying and recruiting participants for the expert panel, (II) addressing participant attrition between rounds, (III) justifying the most appropriate cutoff points, (IV) incorporating new items raised by participants in open-ended survey sections, and (V) ensuring maximum variation in perspective in the panel of experts. Insights from this work foster greater understanding of the underlying assumptions for, and interpretation of, 'modified' in modified Delphi studies. This study will encourage critical dialogue about points of methodological contention in Delphi methodology and thus are relevant for scaling the use of modified Delphi studies in public health, including global health research.
Trauma-informed healthcare systems: an evaluation of trauma-informed care training for hospital-based healthcare professionals in the aftermath of the 2023 earthquakes in Türkiye.
Şimşek Z, Uğur B
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Feb · PMID 39658005 · Full text
Disasters are complex global problems with an increasing impact with rising prevalence of associated illness, mortality, and intensifying health inequities. In recent years, there has been an emphasis on integrating trau...
Disasters are complex global problems with an increasing impact with rising prevalence of associated illness, mortality, and intensifying health inequities. In recent years, there has been an emphasis on integrating trauma-informed care approaches into health policies and protocols. The purpose of the current study was to investigate the benefits of a trauma-informed healthcare training program for hospital-based healthcare providers with a focus on knowledge acquisition, empowerment of professional practice, and personal well-being. The program was implemented in the aftermath of the 2023 earthquakes in southeastern Türkiye. The training consisted of four modules, developed based on psychological trauma theories and behavior change theories, and was evaluated using a mixed-methods approach. Assessments were conducted at the end of the training program, at baseline, and at a 6-month follow-up. A structured questionnaire including items covering the content of the training, trainer effectiveness, and program suitability was administered at the end of the training program. At 6 months, participants completed an 18-item follow-up questionnaire which assessed their understanding of the principles of the trauma-informed care approach. The Maslach Burnout Inventory (MTI) was also administered, and themes regarding the impact of the training program were extracted through in-depth individual qualitative interviews. Data were obtained from 501 program participants. The intervention program was found to improve healthcare workers' understanding of trauma, professional practices, and interpersonal relationships, and significantly reduced symptoms of burnout. These results demonstrate the critical role of trauma-informed training programs in hospitals in disaster-affected regions, especially when assistance to survivors will be enhanced by strengthening healthcare workers' resilience and improving their perceptions of service efficacy and value. The study highlights the need for more widespread adoption of these training initiatives and emphasizes that they may play significant future roles in transforming trauma-informed healthcare systems in disaster-prone countries and regions.
Conceptualizing maternal mental health in rural Ghana: a realist qualitative analysis.
Yevoo LL, Manzano A, Gyimah L … +5 more , Kane S, Awini E, Danso-Appiah A, Agyepong IA, Mirzoev T
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Feb · PMID 39611444 · Full text
In low- and middle-income countries, maternal mental health needs remain neglected, and common mental disorders during pregnancy and after birth are routinely associated with hormonal changes. The psycho-social and spiri...
In low- and middle-income countries, maternal mental health needs remain neglected, and common mental disorders during pregnancy and after birth are routinely associated with hormonal changes. The psycho-social and spiritual components of childbirth are often downplayed. A qualitative study was conducted as part of a wider realist evaluation on health systems responsiveness to examine the interrelationships between pregnant and postnatal women, their families, and their environment, and how these influence women's interactions with healthcare providers in Ghana. Data collection methods combined six qualitative interviews (n = 6) and 18 focus group discussions (n = 121) with pregnant and postnatal women, their relatives, and healthcare providers (midwives, community mental health nurses) at the primary healthcare level. Data analysis was based on the context-mechanism-outcome heuristic of realist evaluation methodology. A programme theory was developed and iteratively refined, drawing on Crowther's ecology of birth theory to unpack how context shapes women's interactions with public and alternative healthcare providers. We found that context interacts dynamically with embodiment, relationality, temporality, spatiality, and mystery of childbirth experiences, which in turn influence women's wellbeing in three primary areas. There is an intricate intersection of pregnancy with mental health impacting women's expectations of temporality, which does not always coincide with the timings provided by formal healthcare services. Societal deficiencies in social support structures for women facing economic challenges become particularly evident during the pregnancy and postnatal period, where women need heightened assistance. Socio-cultural beliefs associated with the mystery of childbirth, the supportive role of private providers and faith healing practices offered women a feeling of protection from uncertainty. Co-production of context-specific interventions, including the integration of maternal and mental health policies, with relevant stakeholders can help formal healthcare providers accommodate women's perspectives on spirituality and mental health, which can subsequently help to make health systems responsive to maternal mental health conditions.
Managing medicines in decentralization: discrepancies between national policies and local practices in primary healthcare settings in Indonesia.
Fanda RB, Probandari A, Kok MO … +1 more , Bal RA
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39576064 · Full text
In Indonesia, primary health centres (PHCs) are mandated to provide essential medicines to ensure equal access to medication for all Indonesians, as stated in the national medicine policy. However, limited information is...
In Indonesia, primary health centres (PHCs) are mandated to provide essential medicines to ensure equal access to medication for all Indonesians, as stated in the national medicine policy. However, limited information is available regarding the actual practices of health workers within the context of decentralized governance. This paper investigates the discrepancies between national policies and local practices in two Indonesian districts, shedding light on coping mechanisms employed in each phase of medicine management within PHCs. The mixed-method study began by identifying pertinent policies addressing medicine management in PHCs. Subsequently, panel data on patient visits to tuberculosis, maternal and neonatal health (MNH), and noncommunicable disease (NCD) services were collected from 2019 to 2022. After analysing the panel data, interviews were conducted with 56 health workers including physicians, nurses, pharmacists, midwives, and public health programme managers regarding their views on fluctuations in medicine stocks and the patient visit data. These participants included pharmacists and programme managers specializing in tuberculosis, MNH, and NCD care and were affiliated with PHCs and district health offices. Our findings highlight the occasional unavailability of essential medicines in PHCs, with stockouts being attributed to supplier shortages at provincial and national levels and to variations in the capacity of the local health system. Low-skilled pharmaceutical staff are a contributing factor in each phase of medicine management. Additionally, health workers employ coping mechanisms, such as deviating from policy on the use of capitation funds to purchase medicines, to manage temporary stockouts. To tackle systemic stockouts, central government should prioritize capacity-building among health workers, by establishing a continuous and easily accessible local learning system.
Learning analysis of health system resilience.
Thu KM, Bernays S, Abimbola S
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39575662 · Full text
The emergence of 'resilience' as a concept for analysing health systems-especially in low- and middle-income countries-has been trailed by debates on whether 'resilience' is a process or an outcome. This debate poses a m...
The emergence of 'resilience' as a concept for analysing health systems-especially in low- and middle-income countries-has been trailed by debates on whether 'resilience' is a process or an outcome. This debate poses a methodological challenge. What 'health system resilience' is interpreted to mean shapes the approach taken to its analysis. To address this methodological challenge, we propose 'learning' as a concept versatile enough to navigate the 'process versus outcome' tension. Learning-defined as 'the development of insights, knowledge, and associations between past actions, the effectiveness of those actions, and future actions'-we argue, can animate features that tend to be silenced in analyses of resilience. As with learning, the processes involved in resilience are cyclical: from absorption to adaptation, to transformation, and then to anticipation of future disruption. Learning illuminates how resilience occurs-or fails to occur-interactively and iteratively within complex systems while acknowledging the contextual, cognitive, and behavioural capabilities of individuals, teams, and organizations that contribute to a system's emergence from or evolution given shocks/stress. Learning analysis can help to resist the pull towards framing resilience as an outcome-as resilience is commonly used to mean or suggest a state or an attribute, rather than a process that unfolds, whether the outcomes are deemed positive or not. Analysing resilience as a learning process can help health systems researchers better systematically make sense of health system responses to present and future stress/shocks. In qualitative or quantitative analyses, seeing what is to be analysed as 'learning' rather than the more nebulous 'resilience' can refocus attention on what is to be measured, explained, and how-premised on the understanding that a health system with the ability to learn is the one with the ability to be resilient, regardless of the outcome of such a process.
What is the relationship between hospital management practices and quality of care? A systematic review of the global evidence.
Ward C, Phiri ERM, Goodman C … +5 more , Nyondo-Mipando AL, Malata M, Manda WC, Mwapasa V, Powell-Jackson T
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Mar · PMID 39575503 · Full text
There is a widely held view that good management improves organizational performance. However, hospitals are complex organizations, and the relationship between management practices and health service delivery is not str...
There is a widely held view that good management improves organizational performance. However, hospitals are complex organizations, and the relationship between management practices and health service delivery is not straightforward. We conducted a global, systematic literature review of the quantitative evidence on the link between the adoption of management practices and quality of care in hospitals. We searched in PubMed, EMBASE, EconLit, Global Health, and Web of Science on 16 October 2024, without language or country restrictions. We included empirical studies from 1 January 2000 onwards, examining the quantitative association between hospital management practices and quality of care. Outcomes included structural quality (availability of resources such as drugs and equipment), clinical quality (adherence to guidelines), health outcomes, and patient satisfaction or experience with care. In every study, each tested association was categorized as significantly positive (at the 5% level), null, or significantly negative. The study was registered with PROSPERO (CRD42022301462). Of 11 731 articles, 25 studies met the inclusion criteria and had an acceptable risk of bias. Studies were equally distributed between high-income and low- and middle-income countries, with 22 cross-sectional and three intervention studies. Of 111 associations, 55 (49.5%) were significantly positive, one (1%) was significantly negative, and 55 (49.5%) were null. Among the associations tested, the majority were significantly positive for structural quality (79%), clinical quality (60%), and health outcomes (57%), while most associations between hospital management and patient satisfaction (80%) were null. The findings are mixed, with a similar proportion of positive and null associations between management practices and quality of care across studies. The evidence is limited by the risk of bias introduced by nonrandomized study designs. Evidence of positive associations in some settings warrants further investigation of the association through intervention studies or natural experiments. This could leverage methodological developments in quantitatively measuring management, highlighted by this review.
Correction to: Improving antibiotic use through behaviour change: a systematic review of interventions evaluated in low- and middle-income countries.
Health Policy Plan · 2025 Jan · PMID 39573862 · Full text
Abstract loading — click title to view on PubMed.
About
- Frequency
- Sun
- Papers found
- 200
- RSS feed
- Subscribe